Deeper Dives

The Financial Investigation:

Your Guide to Uncovering
Every Dollar in an Ohio Divorce

For a spouse who has not been the primary financial manager, divorce can feel like stepping off a cliff in the dark. It is a terrifying feeling, defined by a single, looping question: "What if I don't even know what to ask for?"

We hear this fear every day. "My spouse always handled the money." "I don't know where all the accounts are." "I'm afraid they're hiding something, but I feel powerless to find it."

Let's be perfectly clear: You are not powerless. You were a partner in a marriage who trusted your spouse to handle the finances. The feeling of vulnerability is overwhelming, but it is not permanent.

The law is on your side. In an Ohio divorce, you have a legal right to a complete financial disclosure from your spouse. The "villain" is uncertainty and a system that processes cases quickly, not fairly. Our "plan" to defeat that villain is a methodical, comprehensive financial review process.

Its purpose is simple: to move you from confusion and fear to clarity and empowerment. It is a diagnostic tool that turns on the lights, levels the playing field, and ensures that the final settlement is based on a complete and accurate picture of your family's finances. This guide will walk you through the entire process, step by step.

Part 1: The "Why"—The Purpose of the Financial X-Ray

You cannot negotiate a fair settlement if you are working with incomplete information. It's like asking a doctor to perform surgery with no MRI or X-Ray. You would never agree to it. Yet, people agree to settlements based on a single tax return and a "promise" from their spouse that "this is everything."

The financial investigation (known legally as "discovery") has three primary goals:

  1. Identify All Assets and Debts: To find every bank account, retirement account, investment, real estate holding, and credit card.

  2. Determine the True "Marital Estate": To "trace" and separate any assets you or your spouse brought into the marriage (separate property) from the assets you acquired together (marital property).

  3. Establish the "Standard of Living": To document your family's *actual* income and spending, which is the foundation for any spousal support calculation.

This process is your single greatest tool for moving from a place of vulnerability to a position of strength.

Part 2: Phase 1—The Informal Exchange (The "Easy Way")

The first step in our plan is always the simplest. We begin by providing your spouse's attorney with a comprehensive list of documents sought, based on the document list in our "From Fear to Freedom" Ebook. This is an informal, good-faith request. In many cases, especially dissolutions, this voluntary exchange is all that is needed.

This checklist is far more than just "bank statements." We are looking for patterns. Here is what we ask for and why it's so critical:

A. Income and Tax Documents (The "Big Picture")

What we ask for: The last 3-5 years of personal and business tax returns (federal, state, and local), including *all* W-2s, 1099s, and K-1s.

Why: A single tax return doesn't tell a story. Five years shows us income trends. More importantly, the *schedules* tell us where to look next:

  • Schedule A** shows property taxes (revealing real estate you may not know about).

  • Schedule B** shows interest and dividends (revealing bank and brokerage accounts).

  • Schedule C** reveals a side business.

  • Schedule D** shows stock sales (revealing investment activity).

  • Schedule E** shows rental income or partnership income.

B. Asset and Debt Statements (The "Hard Numbers")

What we ask for: 12-24 months of statements for *all* accounts: checking, savings, credit cards, mortgages, car loans, brokerage accounts, 401(k)s, IRAs, pensions, and life insurance.

Why: This is the core of the X-Ray.

  • Bank Statements: We look for large, unexplained withdrawals or consistent transfers to unknown accounts. This is the #1 way we spot hidden assets.

  • Credit Card Statements: This is a roadmap to your "standard of living." We analyze these to build your monthly budget, which is the evidence used to argue for spousal support. It also reveals spending patterns—large gifts, travel, or hotel stays—that could indicate marital funds are being "dissipated" (wasted).

  • Retirement Statements: This helps us calculate the "marital portion" of each account, which is critical for securing your fair share. This directly relates to the questions in our A&A post, "How Can I Ensure I Receive My Fair Share of My Spouse's Pension or 401(k)?"

C. Other Key Documents

What we ask for: Paystubs, employment contracts, lists of business "perks" (car allowance, club memberships), property deeds, and vehicle titles.

Why: These documents fill in the gaps. An employment contract can reveal a guaranteed bonus or a future stock grant that is a marital asset. A car title might be in your spouse's name, but if it was paid for with marital funds, it's a marital asset.

Part 3: Phase 2—Formal Discovery (The "Power Tools")

What happens if your spouse refuses to provide these documents? What if they send an incomplete, blacked-out, or fraudulent stack of paper?

This is where your feeling of powerlessness ends. This is where your guide (your lawyer) steps in and uses the formal power of the legal system. You no longer have to be the one asking.

Tool 1: Interrogatories

What they are: A formal list of written questions that your spouse must answer, under oath.

Why they work: Lying on an Interrogatory is perjury, a crime. This forces a level of honesty you cannot get in a simple conversation.

Sample Questions:

  • List every bank account you have had an interest in for the past 5 years."

  • Have you received any gift or inheritance valued over $1,000 during the marriage? If so, state the amount, date, and where the funds are currently held."

  • List all sources of income, including 'under the table' cash, you have received in the past 36 months."

Tool 2: Requests for Production of Documents

What they are: This is the legally-binding "hammer" for our checklist. It's a formal demand for the documents themselves—the bank statements, the business records, the tax returns.

Why they work: A simple request can be ignored. A formal demand carries the weight of the court.

Tool 3: Subpoenas

What they are: This is your most powerful tool. A subpoena is a legal order we issue directly to a third party.

Why they work: This tool allows us to go around your spouse. We don't need their cooperation to get the truth. We can subpoena:

  • The Bank** (for all account statements).

  • The Employer** (for payroll, bonus, and retirement plan information).

  • The Credit Card Company** (for all statements).

  • A New Partner** (if we suspect marital assets are being spent on them).

  • The "Friendly Loan" Relative** (to prove a "loan" was actually a gift).

This single tool is often the key to moving a client from fear to empowerment.

Tool 4: Depositions

What they are: This is a formal, in-person (or video) interview with your spouse, conducted under oath with a court reporter present.

Why they work: This is our chance to ask "why." We have the bank statements in hand. "I see on this statement you transferred $50,000 to an account in the Cayman Islands. What was the purpose of that transfer?" This locks in their testimony long before a trial, which is powerful leverage for settlement.

Part 4: Phase 3—The Expert Analysis (The "Deep Dive")

Once we have the mountain of data, we need a guide to interpret it. For complex, high-asset cases, we bring in a forensic accountant or valuation expert. This is the team that performs a financial X-Ray on the documents you've gathered.

Tracing Separate Property

This is a critical function for our clients over 45 who may have received an inheritance or brought pre-marital assets into a long-term marriage.

The Rule: In Ohio, any asset you owned before your marriage, or any gift or inheritance *to you alone during the marriage, is your separate property.

The Catch: ...if you can trace it.

The Villain ("Commingling"): If you put your $100,000 inheritance into a joint checking account, and that money was used for 10 years of groceries, vacations, and bills, it has been "commingled" and is likely lost. It has become a marital asset.

The Plan ("Tracing"): If you put that $100,000 into a separate brokerage account, never added marital funds, and it grew to $250,000, we can help you "trace" it. A forensic expert will analyze the statements from inception to the present, proving that the entire $250,000 (the initial principal and its passive growth) is your separate property, and it is off the table for division.

When Your Spouse Won't Cooperate: The Motion to Compel

What if your spouse ignores the Interrogatories? What if they refuse to show up for a deposition? This is not a dead end.

We file a "Motion to Compel" with the court. The judge will then issue a direct order forcing your spouse to comply. If they *still* refuse, the judge can sanction them (make them pay your attorney's fees) or even hold them in contempt of court. You are never powerless.

Success vs. Failure: Why This Matters

The Failure: You skip this process to "save money" or "be nice." You negotiate a settlement based on a single tax return. You lose hard-earned wealth and business interests because you didn't know they existed. You get an unfair support order. Years later, you are trapped in financial uncertainty, knowing you left money on the table.

The Success: You follow the plan. You conduct a thorough financial X-Ray. You now have a complete, transparent balance sheet of your marital estate. You can negotiate from a position of strength and confidence. You move forward faster, focusing on your future, with the financial security you deserve. You are empowered.

From Confusion to Empowerment: Your Next Step

The financial X-Ray process is the single most important step in moving from fear to freedom. A fair settlement is impossible if it's based on incomplete information.

For a complete checklist of documents to start gathering today, download our free "From Fear to Freedom" Ebook.

Knowing what to look for is the first step. The next is having a guide who knows how to get it. Your next step is our Build Your Divorce Plan:

  1. Schedule a simple phone appointment.

  2. Understand your legal options and the power of the discovery process.

  3. Execute your plan with confidence.

We simplify divorce to empower your future.

If you are ready to choose a better path forward for you and your family, take the first step. Schedule a confidential consultation with The Fogelman Law Firm, and let us show you how to navigate your divorce with the dignity you all deserve.

Schedule your free, confidential consultation

This is ADVERTISING MATERIAL ONLY.

Disclaimer: All articles and posts are for informational purposes only. This information was current as of the posting date. The information does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for hiring an attorney to review your specific legal issue. By reading this site you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and The Fogelman Law Firm LLC. To form an attorney client relationship, you must contact us, appear for a consultation, tender payment of a security retainer, and sign a retention agreement before this firm will represent you.